When Max Pacioretty was named captain of the Montreal Canadiens, we all knew, or almost all of us, that this choice didn't really make sense. "Patch" has nothing of a natural captain to bring the "jet" to the right landing strip. When he was named, the fight was between him and P.K. Subban. Two guys who don't have the makings of such a role.
I also remember that at the time, Michel Villeneuve took the liberty of reporting that Michel Therrien had indicated, over a beer after a game of golf, that Pacioretty was the worst captain in Montreal Canadiens history. Therrien obviously denied this rumor, but according to one of my contacts, the former Canadiens head coach really allowed himself to throw that around.
That said, Stephane Waite, who was in the locker room when Max Pacioretty was named, spoke out about it and let's just say we weren't in the left field.